Blog

/
/
Q4: The Deal That Closed Out the Year, but at What Cost?

Q4: The Deal That Closed Out the Year, but at What Cost?

העלות האמיתית של עסקת סוף שנה

The annual sales target is within reach, the customer wants a discount, and the deal looks like a win. So why isn’t the CFO in a hurry to celebrate?

It’s December. The sales report is up on the screen. The annual target looks closer than ever, and the team is already discussing how to close the gap before the end of the month. Then comes the news: a major customer is willing to sign another deal, provided it gets a 15% discount and 120 days to pay. The sales director sees a chance to end the year with a strong sales figure. The CFO looks at the same offer and asks a different question: how much will we actually make on this deal?

15% Off the Price, 43% Less Gross Profit: What Does a Year-End Discount Really Mean?

This is a hypothetical example, but the dilemma is familiar to many companies at year-end. The numbers may vary from one deal to the next, but the lesson holds.

Suppose the deal is priced at $100,000 and costs $65,000 to deliver. At full price, it generates $35,000 in gross profit. With a 15% discount, revenue falls to $85,000, but the cost of delivering the product or service stays the same. Gross profit drops to just $20,000. In other words, cutting the price by 15% wipes out nearly 43% of the expected gross profit.

Those numbers show how much pricing matters. In its analysis of a typical S&P 500 company, McKinsey estimated that a 1% improvement in price could increase profitability by about 6%.

Does that mean the company should walk away? Not necessarily. If the alternative is no sale at all, $20,000 in gross profit may still make the deal worthwhile. What else should management consider before making the call?

The Contract Is Signed in December. Payment Is Due in April.

Back to our example. Suppose the company delivers the product and issues the invoice at the end of December. With 120-day payment terms, payment isn’t due until late April. In the meantime, the company still has to pay its employees and suppliers, so the deal can put pressure on cash flow for months.

There’s also an accounting question. Signing a contract in December doesn’t guarantee that the revenue will be recognized in that year’s financial statements. Under IFRS 15, the timing depends on when or as the company fulfills its obligations to the customer.

So what should management do? The real test of Q4 is not just how many deals the company closes by December 31. It’s what those deals leave the company with when the new year begins.

That’s where the CFO comes in. The point isn’t to stop the sale, but to see whether it can become a better deal. Would the customer accept a smaller discount in exchange for an upfront payment? Could the work and payments be split into milestones? Or would it make sense to approve the deal as offered after weighing profitability and cash flow?

That’s the value a good CFO brings, including the outsourced CFOs at Danoy. They look beyond the numbers to help management understand what’s behind each deal, weigh the risks and opportunities, and make decisions that serve the business over the long term.

Want that kind of financial perspective in your own company? Talk to us.

Skip to content